According to the 1796 Prospect of Philadelphia, it was "Nearly opposite the Sign of the Indian Queen, in Fourth-street."
(1785) #1 Rutter's Alley, vacant or residents would not give name
(1785) #8 Rutter's Alley, Humphreys, Samuel
(1785) #9 Rutter's Alley, Rutter, Henry
(1785) #10 Rutter's Alley, Tottness, John
(1785) #11 Rutter's Alley, Steinmetz, Daniel
(1785) #12 Rutter's Alley, Keating, Widow
(1785) #13 Rutter's Alley, Scull, Benjamin
(1785) #305 Rutter's Alley, Rutter, Moses
(1785) #447 Rutter's Alley, Rutter, Jacob, shopkeeper